Why Collaboration Matters
Feedback and Noise Are Not the Same
Feedback Has Context, Noise Has Volume
How To Differentiate Them
Brick by Brick Beats Forced Momentum
Designing in isolation is risky. Collaborating with other designers introduces perspectives you wouldn’t reach on your own. It helps uncover blind spots, challenge assumptions, and surface better alternatives early on. More importantly, it keeps decisions from being driven by ego, mine or anyone else’s.
Good collaboration creates clarity. It shifts conversations from who’s right to what works best. When ideas are discussed openly, design decisions become stronger, more intentional, and easier to stand behind.
Not everything that comes back from collaboration is feedback. Some of it is noise. Early on, I treated all input equally. If someone had an opinion, I assumed it deserved the same weight as everything else. Over time, I realized that this approach creates confusion instead of clarity.
Feedback helps refine a product.
Noise distracts it.
The challenge isn’t avoiding input—it’s knowing how to interpret it.
Feedback is rooted in context. It comes from understanding the user, the problem being solved, and the situation in which something breaks or feels unclear. Even when it’s critical, it points toward an underlying issue worth examining.
Noise, on the other hand, is loud but shallow. It’s often driven by personal preference, isolated scenarios, or opinions detached from the product’s intent. Noise feels urgent, but urgency doesn’t equal importance.
The difference isn’t how strongly something is said—it’s how deeply it’s grounded.
Differentiating between feedback and noise requires judgment. I’ve learned to slow down and ask a few simple questions:
Who is this coming from?
What problem are they actually experiencing?
Does this align with the core goal of the product?
If a comment reveals friction or misunderstanding, it’s worth exploring. If it introduces preference without purpose, it’s usually noise. Good design decisions come from synthesis—not reaction.
When every opinion turns into a change, products lose coherence. Interfaces become cluttered, flows grow complex, and clarity fades. Each decision might make sense on its own, but together they dilute the experience.
Designing well means protecting the core experience—the primary user, the primary flow, and the primary intent. Saying no thoughtfully is just as important as saying yes because after all the only thing that matters is the IDEA.
About
Work
Connect
Notebook
Feedback vs Noise - What's the Difference?
God Bless the White Monster Energy.